Here's something the insurance industry would rather you not think about: the friendly adjuster who calls after your accident is not on your side. They work for a company whose profit depends on paying injury claims as cheaply as possible. That doesn't make them villains — it makes them professionals doing a job. But you should understand what that job actually is before you talk to them.
This guide walks through the tactics insurance companies use against injury victims — not to make you paranoid, but to make you prepared. Most of these work only because people don't see them coming.
01 — The adjuster isn't your friend.
Insurance adjusters are trained to be pleasant, sympathetic, and reassuring. That's not an accident — it's a strategy. A victim who feels taken care of is less likely to hire a lawyer, less likely to push back on a low offer, and more likely to say something that can be used to reduce the claim. The warmth is real in tone and false in purpose. Keep that in mind every time you pick up the phone.
02 — Why they call immediately.
If the other driver's insurer calls you within a day or two of the crash, that speed is deliberate. They want to reach you:
- Before you've seen a doctor — so they can argue you "weren't really hurt."
- Before you understand your injuries — so they can lock in a cheap settlement before you know you need surgery.
- Before you hire a lawyer — because represented claimants recover more, and they know it.
- While you're stressed and disoriented — when you're most likely to say something unhelpful.
03 — The recorded statement trap.
One of the first things the other side's adjuster will ask for is a "quick recorded statement, just to document what happened." Decline. You are almost never required to give one to the at-fault party's insurer. These statements are designed to extract admissions: questions are phrased to get you to minimize your injuries ("but you're feeling okay now, right?"), guess about facts you don't actually know, or accept partial blame. A casual "I'm fine, thanks" recorded on day two becomes Exhibit A when you're still in physical therapy six months later.
Your own insurer may require a statement under your policy's cooperation clause — that's different, and we'll help you navigate it. But the at-fault party's insurer is building a case against your claim. Politely decline and refer them to your attorney.
04 — The lowball first offer.
Quick settlement offers feel like a relief when bills are piling up. That's exactly why they're made early and made low. A first offer is typically a fraction of a claim's real value — and once you sign the release, your case is closed forever. If you discover next month that you need surgery, or that your back injury is permanent, you're out of luck. The release doesn't reopen. We never let a client accept an offer before the full scope of their injuries and future medical needs is understood.
The first offer isn't an offer to make you whole. It's an offer to make you go away cheaply.
05 — Social media surveillance.
Insurance companies routinely monitor claimants' social media — and sometimes hire private investigators. A photo of you smiling at a family barbecue, a check-in at the gym, or a post about a weekend hike can be twisted into "proof" that you aren't really injured, even if you spent the next three days in bed paying for it. While your case is active:
- Set your accounts to private (though assume nothing is truly private).
- Don't post about the accident, your injuries, or your activities.
- Ask friends and family not to tag you.
- Don't delete existing posts once a claim is underway — that can be treated as destroying evidence. Just stop adding new ones.
06 — Delay, deny, defend.
For larger claims, some insurers follow a well-documented strategy: delay the process, deny what they can, and defend aggressively if you push. The goal is to wear you down. Medical bills mount, savings run out, and eventually a stressed claimant accepts far less than the case is worth just to end it. A lawyer changes that calculation — because the insurer now knows the alternative to a fair settlement is litigation. In Texas, the Stowers doctrine and prompt-pay laws give us real leverage against bad-faith delay.
07 — The "independent" medical exam.
At some point the insurer may demand an "independent medical examination" (IME). There's nothing independent about it — the doctor is selected and paid by the insurance company, and many earn substantial income performing these exams with predictable conclusions: your injuries are minor, pre-existing, or already healed. We prepare clients for IMEs and, when necessary, counter them with your treating physicians' records and independent expert opinions.
08 — How to protect yourself.
- Get medical care and follow through. Gaps in treatment are the first thing insurers exploit.
- Don't give recorded statements to the at-fault insurer.
- Don't accept the first offer — or any offer — without having it evaluated.
- Stay off social media about your accident and activities.
- Keep records of everything: bills, mileage, missed work, out-of-pocket costs.
- Talk to a lawyer early. Most offer free consultations, and representation typically increases recovery even after fees.
None of this requires being combative. It just requires understanding that the process is adversarial even when the tone is friendly. That's the whole game. Once you see it, you can't unsee it — and you won't get bullied.